The Biggest Gambles In The Toy & Gadget Game


It’s always a gamble when you launch a product; you never know quite how it’s going to turn out. It could be a success or an utter failure – but it’s not always down to something you might expect like market share or advertising.

Sometimes the toy and gadget market pops out something weird and wonderful that you never would have expected. There have been numerous examples of this over the years. From the Slinky in the 40’s to the Tamagotchi in the 90’s – you never know what will resonate with people.

Seriously, who would have thought that the slinky would be a good idea? If you pitched the idea to investors today they’d probably make a funny face. But it’s estimated 250,000,000 have been sold!
So let’s take a look at some of the most unexpected payoffs in the gadget industry.

The Pet Rock

This sounds like the mad ramblings of a man with some incurable brain disease. It’s apparently quite important to have an open mind when thinking about potentially successful gadgets – as was the case for the Pet Rock’s inventor Gary Dahl.

Dahl worked as an advertising executive in the 1970’s and apparently sat drinking in a bar one night listening to friends complain about how their pets were misbehaving.

According to his biography “one night in 1975, an out-of-work advertising executive named Gary Dahl was hanging out in a bar listening to his friends complain about their pets. It gave him an idea for the perfect "pet": a rock.”

He made a million dollars apparently, and that’s a million in the 1970’s – which is quite a payoff from a gamble which, let’s face it, would not have the greatest odds going in. It was an interesting fad of the 70’s, and Dahl attempted to follow it up with some lesser known inventions that didn’t quite grab the attention of the public.

It was inevitable that the fad would die out. According to an interview with Dahl in the Milwaukee journal in 1975 he believed “No one will ever do it again” when talking about the ridiculous pay off.

He didn’t have the greatest time after the success though, with many people coming to him with their hands out looking for money after the publicity that ensued. Speaking in the same interview he said “It made me too high profile. There’s a bizarre lunatic fringe that believe I owe them a living. I don’t know if it’s been an asset or a liability.”

Well then, it looks like the gamble didn’t entirely pay off…
Gary Dahl, and his Pet Rock.

RC Handy Mop


Just when you thought humanity couldn’t get any lazier, someone comes up with this. The RC handy mop has to be one of the weirdest remote control toys I’ve ever seen. It is weird, but also a gamble that apparently was worth taking.

I suppose this gamble was a bit more well-thought out than The Pet Rock, as nobody really likes mopping the floor. So it’s really more of a labour saving device than a bizarre fad invention. It’s a good way to trick kids into pitching in with the household chores too.

This particular gamble comes from Japan, with the Kyosho Corporation making a departure from their usual lines of RC cars and other toys into this. It could be interesting, but I don’t think it will be breaking any records. Kyosho will probably be sticking to their guns making more traditional remote control toys like cars and airplanes.

See the ad for the RC mop below…

Food Fighters

Okay, well if you don’t shoot you don’t score. That’s the lesson. We’ve looked at a hit with the Pet Rock, a maybe with the RC mop and now – a miss. Food Fighters were the brainchild of some clearly out of touch corporate executives at Mattel, Inc in the late 1980’s.

Some bold choices were made when coming up with these. The range was divided into good guys and bad guys, with Kitchen Commandos being good and the Refrigerator Rejects being bad. It never quite took off.
Mattel apparently refused to make the ‘good guy’ characters health foods as these were thought not to resonate with children. As a result, there were plenty of interesting characters including Private Pizza and Taco Terror – but the whole thing was just too weird for people to swallow.

The second hand market is a good place for these gastronomic gadget gambles though, so there is certainly a collectible value to these. The gamble didn’t pay off for Mattel, although it may have paid off for the keen eyed collector who thought they were so bizarre he bought a load upon their initial release – the figures fetch around $20 on eBay currently.

There’s an interesting trailer below. It’s in French, which is bizarre because they’re known for their finer foods as opposed to Lieutenant Leg (a chicken leg) who clearly is a bit more junk food oriented.

The Slinky

Well I mentioned it earlier, so it would be a little bit unfair if I didn’t include it. Obviously, the Slinky was a hit. It’s a simple invention that is still made today, it didn’t die out like the Pet Rock – so it’s clearly got something of a little bit more substance to it. It clearly resonates.

It’s something about the simplicity I think. It’s a coiled wire that just moves in an appealing way. It also takes advantage of physical forces of motion, which makes it extra appealing to people who are interested in such things – most notably Hooke’s Law.

It was invented by Richard James, a naval engineer, and presented at the prestigious Gimbels department store in Philadelphia where it sold out within ninety minutes. Part of the explanation of its popularity is that it was always very cheap – priced at $1.

Like I mentioned in the introduction, it is estimated that over 250,000,000 have been sold and that would suggest that the gamble of Richard James paid off. But, life is a little bit more complicated than that – James’ divorced his wife Betty in 1960 and allegedly joined a cult in Bolivia. Talk about walking away from a golden opportunity.

Betty James chose to continue the business though, and made over $1 billion dollars in her first two years according to Tim Walsh in his book “Timeless Toys: Classic Toys And The Playmakers Who Created Them”.

A slew of other products have followed, including the Slinky Dog which became a character in the 1995 film ‘Toy Story’. It sold 825,000 units in the run up to Christmas that year. There is also a plastic slinky available today.

It was probably the most amazing gamble of all time, seeing that it continues to pay off to this day and is still entirely popular with children and adults alike. Betty James died in 2008, and the legacy of the Slinky continues to live on.

The Greatest Gadget Gambles

Well, there you have some of the greatest gadget gambles – along with some of the worst. It just goes to show you never quite know what will happen when it comes to things like toys and games. Some things just click.

Do you know of a gadget gamble that paid off big – is there one on the horizon I should be aware of? Please feel free to comment. And don’t forget to add me to your circles on Google+ for all the latest.


Visit Technoperative again soon, and contact me if you’d like to make your own contribution.

Comments